Top Realtors and Real Estate Agents in Shelter Island, NY
Rankings based on verified MLS transaction data. Last updated April 2026. No pay-to-play.
Top Agent
(849)
Bryan Karp
Coldwell Banker American Homes
17 Years of experience
305+ Sales in the last 12 months
Top 4.65%
in Shelter Island, NY
$1.2B
All-Time Sales
$410K - $3.3M
Price Range
5%
Negotiated Off List
Top Agent(6)
Gioia DiPaolo
Douglas Elliman
30 Years of experience
2+ Sales in the last 12 months
Top 4.65%
in Shelter Island, NY
$264.6M
All-Time Sales
$1.4M - $14.1M
Price Range
5%
Negotiated Off List
Top Agent(7)
Kristopher Pilles
East End Luxury Ltd.
24 Years of experience
8+ Sales in the last 12 months
Top 0%
in Shelter Island, NY
$134.6M
All-Time Sales
$330K - $2.4M
Price Range
9%
Negotiated Off List
Top Agent(22)
Helene D Mandzik
Little Bay Realty
44 Years of experience
4+ Sales in the last 12 months
Top 0%
in Shelter Island, NY
$101.6M
All-Time Sales
$250K - $2.8M
Price Range
5%
Negotiated Off List
Top Agent
(8)
Neil Tevez
Daniel Gale Sothebys International
23 Years of experience
9+ Sales in the last 12 months
Top 0%
in Shelter Island, NY
$84M
All-Time Sales
$440K - $4.8M
Price Range
50%
Negotiated Off List
Top Agent(2)
Trevor Kemp
East End Luxury Ltd
21 Years of experience
2+ Sales in the last 12 months
Top 0%
in Shelter Island, NY
$37.1M
All-Time Sales
$270K - $2M
Price Range
16%
Negotiated Off List
Top Agent(42)
Brian Hagadorn
Douglas Elliman
11 Years of experience
11+ Sales in the last 12 months
Top 0%
in Shelter Island, NY
$190M
All-Time Sales
$1.7M - $8.3M
Price Range
12%
Negotiated Off List
(17)
Penelope Moore
Penelope Moore Real Estate
0 Years of experience
Top 0%
in Shelter Island, NY
0
Total Number Of Homes Sold
-
Price Range
-
Negotiated Off
(18)
Susan Cincotta
Susan C Cincotta
0 Years of experience
Top 0%
in Shelter Island, NY
0
Total Number Of Homes Sold
-
Price Range
-
Negotiated Off
Shelter island Housing Market Trends
Median Sale Price
$4,075,000
+208.71% year-over-yearMedian Days on Market
192
0 days year-over-yearSale-to-List Price
94.60%
-0.02% year-over-yearMonths of Supply
7.0
Realtors in Shelter island
79
Verified MLS market data through April 2026.
How We Rank Shelter Island Real Estate Agents
Our rankings are built from verified MLS transaction data, not advertising spend. For every agent we analyze more than fifteen performance signals, including sales volume in your city and zip code, recent and all-time transactions, days on market, negotiation results (how far above or below list price an agent's clients actually close), price-point fit, and verified reviews. The agents shown first are those whose verified results put them at the top of the Shelter Island market today.
Agents cannot pay for placement in these rankings. The underlying data refreshes as new closed transactions are reported, so rankings shift with real market performance.
Rankings reviewed by Kevin Stuteville, Licensed Florida Real Estate Broker (License BK3068131), Founder of EffectiveAgents.
Data last updated: April 2026
Shelter Island Real Estate Agent FAQs
How were these Shelter Island real estate agents ranked?
Rankings are built from verified MLS transaction data. We analyze more than fifteen performance signals for every agent, including sales volume in your city and zip code, recent and all-time transactions, days on market, negotiation results, price-point fit, and verified reviews. Agents cannot pay for placement.
How many real estate agents are in Shelter Island?
Our data covers 79 real estate agents serving the Shelter Island area. The count represents agents with transaction activity recorded in our Shelter Island market data, not simply everyone holding a license.
What does the median sale price in Shelter Island mean for sellers?
Shelter Island's median sale price is $4,075,000 as of April 2026. Half of recent sales closed above that figure and half below. It is a useful baseline for understanding the market, but an experienced local agent will price your home against comparable recent sales in your neighborhood, not the citywide median.
Does it cost anything to use EffectiveAgents?
No. EffectiveAgents is free for home buyers and sellers, with no obligation to work with any agent we match you with.
Do agents pay to be ranked or featured?
No. Agents cannot pay for placement anywhere in these rankings. Positions are earned from verified transaction performance only.
What commission do Shelter Island realtors charge?
Commissions are negotiable and vary by agent, service level, and transaction. There is no set rate, and recent industry changes have made commission structures more flexible than ever. Discuss the structure directly with your agent before signing a listing or buyer agreement.
Top Realtors by Zip Code in Shelter Island, NY
Nearby Cities
No nearby cities found
In Shelter Island