EffectiveAgents Agent Awards

    Top Real Estate Agents in Youngstown, OH

    Q2 2026 cycle. Rankings reflect verified sale performance across 517 Youngstown agents, refreshed quarterly. Placement cannot be purchased.

    Holly RitchieHolly RitchieKeller Williams Chervenic Realty#2View profile
    Tibitha MatheneyTibitha MatheneyBurgan Real Estate LTD#3View profile
    Bob RobertsBob RobertsMAYO & ASSOCIATES#5View profile

    Also honored this cycle

    1 agents earned TOP 3%, 1 agents earned TOP 10%. The full ranked list is on the Youngstown top agents page.

    Continue: All top agents in Youngstown, OH • How awards are earned