Tibitha Matheney
Burgan Real Estate LTD
Want to work with Tibitha Matheney?
Top 0.58%
In Youngstown, OH
$22.9M
Total Sales Last Year
23
Years of Experience
107
Recent Transactions
$100K - $1.9M
Average Price Point
Agent Bio
Licensed In Ohio: 2003008663
Discover Agent Performance Insights on Tibitha Matheney. We Analyzed 1,545 Transactions To Help You Decide If Tibitha Is The Best Real Estate Agent Near You.
Office Location
5335 Market St,Youngstown,OH44512
Home Sold by Tibitha Matheney
Agent Achievements
Veteran Agent
Photo Pro
Quick To Respond
Highly Rated
Negotiation Skills
Avg. Savings Off List Price
$9,364
Avg. % Negotiated Off List
6.75%
Tibitha Matheney's Top Cities
Tibitha Matheney's Top Neighborhoods
More Agents Near You
Tibitha Matheney's Recent Sales
Date
01/15/2026
Address
3057 S Meridian Rd, 44511
Price
$147,500
Represented
N/A
Date
01/12/2026
Address
155 Morrison St, OH 44471
Price
$122,000
Represented
Seller
Date
12/29/2025
Address
325 N Yorkshire Blvd, OH 44515
Price
$145,000
Represented
Seller
Date
12/22/2025
Address
6581 N Timberidge Ave, OH 44515
Price
$340,000
Represented
Seller
Date
12/18/2025
Address
6856 Berry Blossom Dr, OH 44406
Price
$305,000
Represented
Seller
Date
12/16/2025
Address
39528 Churchill Rd, OH 44432
Price
$450,000
Represented
Seller
Date
12/15/2025
Address
6261 Whispering Meadows Dr, OH 44406
Price
$469,900
Represented
Seller
Date
12/12/2025
Address
228 Galluppi Ln, OH 44436
Price
$160,000
Represented
Buyer
Date
12/09/2025
Address
51028 State Route 14, OH 44413
Price
$1,200,000
Represented
Seller
Date
12/04/2025
Address
5790 Herbert Rd, OH 44406
Price
$390,000
Represented
Seller
Ratings & Reviews (5)
jeanettefolliett
1 week ago
Tibitha Matheney did her research and suggested a price that would sell quickly. The home sold within three days with a full price offer. She responded quickly to all my messages and answered all my questions thoroughly. I would hire her again.
mamalizia
4 weeks ago
It was a delight to work with Tibitha. She is very knowledgeable about the industry, she is honest when she does an assestment of your house and tells you what to expect. She did a detailed market analysis of other properties around mine and gave me an honest opinion on the value of my house. She was very responsive to any inquiries and alway kept me up to date on anything that was happening with the property. I highly recommend her.
bgaucher24
1 month ago
Tibitha has been an exceptional realtor to work with. Their communication is always clear, timely, and professional, making every step of the process feel smooth and manageable. They are consistently friendly, approachable, and genuinely invested in helping clients succeed. Their dedication and hard-working attitude truly set them apart. I highly recommend Tibitha to anyone looking for a reliable and supportive real estate professional.
mmtoth0
2 months ago
Tibitha did a amazing job helping us get our house. She made sure we could view the house multiple times and got all of the information we needed/requested.
tomiller1973
3 months ago
Tabitha was amazing! She responded to all of my questions without delay. She kept me informed about what was going on with the sale of the house. She is also very professional! I highly recommend her to anyone buying or selling a home or property.