Tibitha Matheney
Burgan Real Estate LTD
Want to work with Tibitha Matheney?
Top 0.58%
In Youngstown, OH
$22.8M
Total Sales Last Year
23
Years of Experience
106
Recent Transactions
$100K - $1.9M
Average Price Point
Agent Bio
Licensed In Ohio: 2003008663
Discover Agent Performance Insights on Tibitha Matheney. We Analyzed 1,551 Transactions To Help You Decide If Tibitha Is The Best Real Estate Agent Near You.
Office Location
5335 Market St,Youngstown,OH44512
Home Sold by Tibitha Matheney
Agent Achievements
Veteran Agent
Photo Pro
Quick To Respond
Highly Rated
Negotiation Skills
Avg. Savings Off List Price
$9,364
Avg. % Negotiated Off List
6.75%
Tibitha Matheney's Top Cities
Tibitha Matheney's Top Neighborhoods
More Agents Near You
Tibitha Matheney's Recent Sales
Date
03/04/2026
Address
4147 Baymar Dr, OH 44511
Price
$200,000
Represented
Seller
Date
03/02/2026
Address
5560 Madrid Dr, OH 44515
Price
$215,000
Represented
Seller
Date
02/27/2026
Address
43 Venloe Dr, OH 44514
Price
$160,000
Represented
Seller
Date
02/20/2026
Address
3673 Nottingham Ave, OH 44511
Price
$225,000
Represented
Seller
Date
01/30/2026
Address
8183 Venice Heights Dr NE, OH 44484
Price
$185,500
Represented
Seller
Date
01/29/2026
Address
2667 Center Rd, OH 44514
Price
$279,900
Represented
Seller
Date
01/15/2026
Address
3057 S Meridian Rd, OH 44511
Price
$147,500
Represented
Seller
Date
01/12/2026
Address
155 Morrison St, OH 44471
Price
$122,000
Represented
Seller
Date
12/29/2025
Address
325 N Yorkshire Blvd, OH 44515
Price
$145,000
Represented
Seller
Date
12/22/2025
Address
6581 N Timberidge Ave, OH 44515
Price
$340,000
Represented
Seller
Ratings & Reviews (5)
jpo825
2 weeks ago
Tibitha and her assistant did an outstanding job helping us sell our house. We purchased the house through Tibitha back in 2012 and knew it was in our best interest to stay with her due to her many years of experience in real estate in our area.
cherry2205
2 weeks ago
Tibitha Matheney is an excellent realtor! She goes above and beyond to help you every step of the way! She is very knowledgeable and works hard to help you through the whole process! With her many years of experience we highly recommend her for all of your real estate needs!!
rphalicki13
1 month ago
Tibitha was referred to us from a friend and did not disappoint! She was clear and concise with us and made selling our father’s home a breeze. Would recommend to anyone in the Youngstown area who is looking to buy or sell their home! She was extremely knowledgeable and great at communicating on all aspects of the process.
jeanettefolliett
2 months ago
Tibitha Matheney did her research and suggested a price that would sell quickly. The home sold within three days with a full price offer. She responded quickly to all my messages and answered all my questions thoroughly. I would hire her again.
mamalizia
2 months ago
It was a delight to work with Tibitha. She is very knowledgeable about the industry, she is honest when she does an assestment of your house and tells you what to expect. She did a detailed market analysis of other properties around mine and gave me an honest opinion on the value of my house. She was very responsive to any inquiries and alway kept me up to date on anything that was happening with the property. I highly recommend her.