Top Agent

    Brenda Sheets

    RE/MAX Realty Team

    stars rating
    113

    Want to work with Brenda Sheets?

    Top 0.19%

    In Fort Myers, FL

    $16.6M

    Total Sales Last Year

    22

    Years of Experience

    51

    Recent Transactions

    $210K - $1.5M

    Average Price Point

    Agent Bio

    Licensed In Florida: 3090100

    Having been raised in beautiful Southwest Florida since their early childhoods, Marty & Brenda Sheets have come to love and appreciate the beautiful beaches, gorgeous sunsets, and many offerings of Lee County. Since Marty & Brenda began their careers in real estate nearly two decades ago, they have grown The Sheets to include seven full-time Realtors, including their son Adam Sheets, Lake Yelton-Alexander, Kimberly Stoutm, Samantha Yelton & Tara kiely. Each team member works with a single, primary purpose ... to ensure that their clients' needs are not only met, but exceeded. Helping each client identify their real estate dreams, and then turning those dreams into reality! Not afraid of challenges, members of The Sheets thrive in finding solutions to difficult situations through both resourcefulness and determination! By your side from start to finish, they will provide you with honest ADVICE and clear explanations; empowering you to make great decisions! Consistently receiving company and office honors, members of The Sheets have received a myriad of recognitions, including inclusion in Gulf Shore Life Magazine's "Top Agents" for 17 years (1 of only 22 agents to accomplish this in their history), as well as the Top 1.5% of America's Best Real Estate Professionals, RE/MAX Platinum Club, Southwest Florida Real Producers Top 500, Seven Star Certificate of Excellence Broker*Agent, and Best of Fort Myers Award in the Real Estate Agents Category, among others. Whether you are buying, selling, or relocating ... a first-time homebuyer, investor, or looking to upgrade or downsize, The Sheets want to be your source for "all things" residential real estate in beautiful Southwest Florida!

    Office Location

    5786 Beechwood Trail,Fort Myers,FL33919

    Home Sold by Brenda Sheets

    Agent Achievements

    Veteran Agent

    Quick To Respond

    Highly Rated

    Negotiation Skills

    Avg. Savings Off List Price

    $35,827

    Avg. % Negotiated Off List

    10.18%

    Brenda Sheets's Recent Sales

    Date

    12/30/2025

    Address

    3977 Button Sage RD, FL 33920

    Price

    $325,000

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    12/19/2025

    Address

    9954 Via San Marco Loop, FL 33905

    Price

    $689,000

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    12/16/2025

    Address

    8049 Country Rd UNIT 101, FL 33919

    Price

    $115,000

    Represented

    N/A

    Date

    12/03/2025

    Address

    14031 W Hyde Park Dr APT 201, FL 33912

    Price

    $349,500

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    11/10/2025

    Address

    8584 Pegasus Dr, FL 33971

    Price

    $389,900

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    10/13/2025

    Address

    1017 Grant Ave, FL 33972

    Price

    $20,000

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    10/03/2025

    Address

    20107 Torch Key Way, FL 33928

    Price

    $430,000

    Represented

    N/A

    Date

    09/26/2025

    Address

    8799 Spring Mountain Way, FL 33908

    Price

    $275,000

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    09/17/2025

    Address

    5028 Billings St, FL 33971

    Price

    $370,000

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    09/12/2025

    Address

    12620 Arbuckle Ct, FL 33903

    Price

    $619,000

    Represented

    Buyer

    Ratings & Reviews (5)

    lilaclavenderandlily

    stars rating

    4 weeks ago

    Brenda Sheets is absolutely amazing to work with! She helped us buy our home and made the entire process smooth, stress-free, and even enjoyable. Brenda is knowledgeable, responsive, and truly had our best interests at heart every step of the way. We felt supported and confident because of her guidance. We couldn’t have asked for a better realtor and highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!

    jefflockshop

    stars rating

    1 month ago

    We had outstanding experience working with Brenda on the purchase of our vacation home in Florida. From the very beginning, Brenda went above and beyond to bridge the distance and make the entire process feel seamless. Communication was exceptional—quick, clear, and always proactive. Brenda provided detailed recommendations based on our preferences and interests, honest insights about each neighborhood, and thoughtful guidance that helped us make informed decisions even from hundreds of miles away. By the time we arrived for a weekend in Florida, Brenda had arranged for all the property tours to take place on one day. She visited each property with us and was able to give us all the feedback we needed so we were able to make an offer before we headed back to RI. What impressed us most was how genuinely they cared about finding the right home us. Brenda was honest, knowledgeable, and consistently advocated for our best interests. When it came time to navigate inspections, negotiations, and closing, she handled every detail with professionalism and confidence, giving us peace of mind throughout. Brenda has continued to be a wonderful resource for us as we continue to navigate getting set up in our new home in Florida. If you are looking for an honest and reliable realtor-Brenda, and her team, will not let you down.

    ray incoming2

    stars rating

    5 months ago

    Over the many years I have been involved in both commercial and residential real estate transactions, I can confidently say that working with Brenda Sheets was an absolute pleasure. She was always on top of everything, responded quickly to inquiries, and provided any information needed to ensure a smooth transaction. I hope to work with her again in the future if I decide to sell my current house. Anyone who has had the fortunate opportunity to work with her understands what I mean. I also appreciate the comprehensive folder she created, which listed all the previous vendors associated with the property. Being able to contact vendors who have previously provided services to the property is extremely important to me, and no one has ever done this for me before. Overall, it was an absolute pleasure working with her.

    user19179175

    stars rating

    5 months ago

    This is the second opportunity we have had to work with Brenda Sheets. Both experiences have been extremely positive. She helped us this year to sell a townhouse/condominium in a very difficult market. Brenda is thorough in her preparation of the property. She gathers all the details of capital improvements, differences from other "similar" units, particular advantages of the location, etc. She was always available when needed and ran numerous open houses. For interested purchasing parties she spent as much time as needed answering, and getting the answers to, questions. Brenda also helped in the purchase of our new home. She was there for the inspection, the walk-through, and other times as needed. She is always willing to help with questions relative to closing. She seeks the best possible outcome for her clients. She is a please to work with and I would highly recommend her to anyone buying or selling a home in SW Florida.

    glenranell

    stars rating

    6 months ago

    Brenda and the whole Sheets family are phenomenal. They are not only kind and courteous, they are honest. They really know what they are doing. They know the market, and kept me well informed every step of the way. And not just in selling my home, but in all the matters involved in transferring to a new home in a new location, which they helped me buy. Brenda always answered or returned my calls quickly. If I had to sell my home, or buy a new home again I would not hesitate to call Brenda.