Matthew Tully
RE/MAX Central
Want to work with Matthew Tully?
Top 0.13%
In Millstone, NJ
$38.9M
Total Sales Last Year
5
Years of Experience
58
Recent Transactions
$460K - $1.7M
Average Price Point
Agent Bio
Licensed In New Jersey: 2075152
**Discover Your Dream Residence with an Award-Winning Expert** Embark on your journey with a group of dedicated professionals. With a profound connection to Monmouth County and the diverse tapestry of New Jersey—my home for over three decades—I am intimately familiar with the unique pulse of our communities. My commitment transcends the ordinary. For me, real estate is about the relationships I foster and the trust I build, culminating in a legacy of satisfied clients who confidently pass my name to friends and family. My mission is simple yet profound: to provide an unparalleled service that translates into your happiness and security, whether you're buying your first cozy nest, scaling the heights to a luxury estate, seeking a savvy investment, or optimizing your commercial portfolio. As a reflection of my dedication, I have been honored with a constellation of accolades, including the prestigious Five Star Professional Market Leader Award for 2022-2023, with special features in Forbes & Fortune Magazines. The NJAR Circle of Excellence recognized my unwavering commitment from 2020-2022. In 2023, I stood among America's Top 100 Real Estate Agents, ranking in the top 1%, a testament to my elite standing in this dynamic industry. My hometown of Manalapan, NJ, bestowed upon me the esteemed 2023 Best of Manalapan Township Award in the Real Estate Professional category, affirming my deep local roots and impact. Additionally, RateMyAgent recognized me as the #2 Realtor in Monmouth County, #4 in New Jersey, and #12 in the Mid-Atlantic Region in 2022, while Zillow lauded me as the "Best of Zillow," highlighting my widespread respect and recognition. But it’s not just awards that define my practice; it’s expertise. I have mastered an array of specialized real estate disciplines, holding coveted designations such as Seller Representative Specialist (SRS), Accredited Buyers Representative (ABR), Pricing Strategy Advisor (PSA), Real Estate Negotiation Expert (RENE), and the tech-savvy e-PRO from the National Association of Realtors. Listening is my forte; I tune into your desires to ensure that every property we explore aligns with your vision. My negotiation and analytical skills are your advantage in a market that demands nothing less than excellence. And when it comes to pricing and marketing your property, I bring precision and strategic acumen to every decision. Let's venture together. Allow me to be the architect of your real estate success, forging a path to your Ultimate Dream Home.
Office Location
1 Koury Lane,Millstone Township,NJ08510
Home Sold by Matthew Tully
Agent Achievements
Photo Pro
Market Leading Agent
Sells Fast
Highly Rated
Negotiation Skills
Avg. Savings Off List Price
$20,656
Avg. % Negotiated Off List
3.44%
Matthew Tully's Top Cities
Matthew Tully's Top Neighborhoods
No top neigborhoods found.
More Agents Near You
Matthew Tully's Recent Sales
Date
11/17/2025
Address
400 Anchor Ave, NJ 8722
Price
$740,000
Represented
Buyer
Date
11/17/2025
Address
804 Timber Oaks Rd, NJ 8820
Price
$470,000
Represented
Seller
Date
11/14/2025
Address
5 Phillips Road, NJ 8724
Price
$420,000
Represented
Buyer
Date
11/07/2025
Address
5 Shady Ln, NJ 8824
Price
$880,000
Represented
Buyer
Date
11/05/2025
Address
1207D Shetland Drive, NJ 8701
Price
$147,500
Represented
Seller
Date
11/05/2025
Address
1207D Shetland Dr, 8701
Price
$147,500
Represented
N/A
Date
10/22/2025
Address
107 Celebration Boulevard, NJ 8723
Price
$527,500
Represented
Seller
Date
10/22/2025
Address
107 Celebration Blvd, 8723
Price
$527,500
Represented
N/A
Date
10/08/2025
Address
15 Haven Way, NJ 7735
Price
$510,000
Represented
Seller
Date
09/26/2025
Address
305 Mountain Ave, NJ 7060
Price
$575,000
Represented
Seller
Ratings & Reviews (5)
maluva810
2 months ago
When I decided to sell my home, I was a little nervous about the process, but Matthew made everything so easy for me. He was a true professional and guided me expertly through every stage. I was especially impressed with how communicative he was and how effortlessly he handled every detail. I am so thrilled with the successful sale and genuinely appreciate all of Matthew's hard work. I will be recommending him to all my friends and family.
zuser20161112165609830
2 months ago
I turned to Matthew to sell my house during a difficult time when I had to pull it off the market after failing to sell it over a period of months and he certainly came through. He found a buyer for me within a week. The entire process went smoothly and was certainly a reflection of Matthew’s commitment and competence. In addition, Matthew was always very responsive and patient with my many questions. It was definitely a pleasant experience.
ginatilton
9 months ago
Matthew Tully is one of the most personable and knowledgeable realtors that I have ever worked with (and I’ve bought and sold 9 houses)! He’s responsive and honest. I would highly recommend Mathew to home buyers and sellers! He sold my house the first day it went on the market!
zuser20170415204208236
1 year ago
Merita was very knowledgeable and helped us during our process of buying a home. I would recommend her to anyone looking for a realtor. The process was smooth and I was comfortable working with her and the team. Thanks again for the great service.
ivisroj
1 year ago
Matthew Tully did an outstanding job helping us sell our home. Matthew was on top of it all, he responded to me quickly and always willing to answer all of my questions. He is very knowledgeable in the field of Real Estate, he was able to give me recommendations for contractors that were very professional. Throughout the sale, Matthew expressed a genuine sense of caring and willingness to help in anything we needed. Although my sale was a challenging one, he remained professional and didn't miss a beat. Most of all, Matthew was able to get us over asking price! I recommend Matthew Tully to all my family and friends.