Top Agent

    James Gilday

    Keller Williams Indpls Metro N

    stars rating
    5

    Want to work with James Gilday?

    Top 0.7%

    In Indianapolis, IN

    $8.7M

    Total Sales Last Year

    19

    Years of Experience

    27

    Recent Transactions

    $130K - $850K

    Average Price Point

    Agent Bio

    Discover Agent Performance Insights on James Gilday. We Analyzed 618 Transactions To Help You Decide If James Is The Best Real Estate Agent Near You.

    Office Location

    11550 North Meridian Street,Carmel,IN46032

    Home Sold by James Gilday

    Agent Achievements

    Veteran Agent

    Photo Pro

    Sells Fast

    Negotiation Skills

    Avg. Savings Off List Price

    $20,518

    Avg. % Negotiated Off List

    13.20%

    James Gilday's Top Zipcodes

    James Gilday's Recent Sales

    Date

    12/16/2025

    Address

    550-548 S Center St, IN 46168

    Price

    $240,000

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    12/05/2025

    Address

    6149 Brokenhurst Rd, IN 46220

    Price

    $325,000

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    11/20/2025

    Address

    1618 N Rural St, IN 46218

    Price

    $210,000

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    10/20/2025

    Address

    2408 Idlewood Dr, IN 46240

    Price

    $20,000

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    09/30/2025

    Address

    6744 Dorchester Dr, IN 46077

    Price

    $320,000

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    09/22/2025

    Address

    215 W Franklin St, IN 46176

    Price

    $127,500

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    09/18/2025

    Address

    926 N Dearborn St, IN 46201

    Price

    $256,000

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    09/12/2025

    Address

    10311 Lakeland Dr, IN 46037

    Price

    $317,500

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    08/29/2025

    Address

    3038 S Richardt Ave, IN 46239

    Price

    $215,000

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    08/22/2025

    Address

    13803 Tender Dr, IN 46032

    Price

    $507,000

    Represented

    Seller

    Ratings & Reviews (5)

    teri4923

    stars rating

    1 month ago

    Exceptional Service and Fast Results! My husband, Adam, and I had the pleasure of working with Jim Gilday and his team to sell our home in October. We were under a tight timeline and required a quick sell to secure our dream house next door. Initially, we contemplated fast-selling through a cash offer company, but that's when Jim reached out. From the onset, Jim exuded professionalism and demonstrated deep market knowledge that gave us the much-needed assurance. We were impressed by his confidence in selling our home swiftly, and even for a higher price than the cash offer companies suggested. Jim brought Tammy, a skilled professional stager/contractor, when he visited our home. Tammy's wide network of professionals spanning landscaping, drywalling, painting, carpeting, and electrical services, among others, gave us an edge in preparing our home for sale. Jim's team transformed our property into a prime pick for potential buyers. The result was nothing short of phenomenal. Our home sold quickly, on schedule, and for our asking price! Throughout the process, Jim remained exceptionally responsive, patient, and helpful in addressing our queries—reinforcing our decision to choose him. His experience and the cohesive teamwork they exhibited were critical factors in the success of our quick home sale. We highly recommend Jim Gilday and his team for anyone seeking a professional, efficient, and highly effective realtor service. Thanks to Jim, we now have our dream house!

    LindaVanPowell

    stars rating

    9 months ago

    Jim listed one of my investment properties for sale. It sat on the market for over 5 weeks with 1 purchase agreement that we accepted but it ended up falling through. He was unable to provide an answer for why that had happened. As it continued to sit on the market I wanted to sell two other investment properties. We were unable to agree to the agent commission rate as his is set to LAC 4.5%, he did agree to reducing it to 4% but we wanted 3%. Therefore we decided to not list the two investment properties with him. We wanted him to focus on selling the one that's been on the market for 5+ weeks. Instead, he sends me a mutual release form. He had overpriced my property and we did two $10k price reduction with still no interest. I would not recommend Jim.

    kharris6974

    stars rating

    1 year ago

    Jim is a top notch realtor and really good guy. He understands the market and gets results. The office staff assisting Jim is diligent and thorough. Communication was exceptional. I always felt like I understood what was happening along the process.

    zuser20180916142125241

    stars rating

    6 years ago

    Jim and his team were great. They all helped me thru this tough time, and made what I thought was going to be a huge headache into a pleasant experience. The fact that he doesn't waste time and gets to the point was refreshing. There was no lapse in communication if I had a question or concern I wasn't waiting for days for a response. I've already recommend The Gilday Group to many friends, neighbors and family. If your in the market I'd recommend them to you as well.

    userHidden

    stars rating

    6 years ago

    Was introduced to Jim through a friend, We are very Pleased and Thankful for Jim! Jim was very patient and understanding with our situation. We are located out of town so he stepped up to care of all areas we needed from lock change once tenant moved to helping with recarpeting and every detail of the sale. He made it as painless as possible with is motivation to get everything done in a timely manner. Thank you for taking care of us and selling the house so quickly!!