Top Agent

    Donald Toscano

    Coldwell Banker Arlene M. Sitterly, Inc.

    stars rating
    53

    Want to work with Donald Toscano?

    Top 0.4%

    In Mayfield, NY

    $2.9M

    Total Sales Last Year

    24

    Years of Experience

    15

    Recent Transactions

    $120K - $470K

    Average Price Point

    Agent Bio

    Licensed In New York: 40TO0940924

    Discover Agent Performance Insights on Donald Toscano. We Analyzed 262 Transactions To Help You Decide If Donald Is The Best Real Estate Agent Near You.

    Office Location

    363 North Comrie Avenue,Johnstown,NY12095

    Home Sold by Donald Toscano

    Agent Achievements

    Veteran Agent

    Photo Pro

    Quick To Respond

    Negotiation Skills

    Avg. Savings Off List Price

    $8,275

    Avg. % Negotiated Off List

    5.20%

    Donald Toscano's Top Neighborhoods

    No top neigborhoods found.

    Donald Toscano's Top Zipcodes

    Donald Toscano's Recent Sales

    Date

    05/16/2025

    Address

    15 Country Club Drive, NY 12078

    Price

    $234,900

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    02/21/2025

    Address

    442 County Hwy 152, NY 12117

    Price

    $380,000

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    02/12/2025

    Address

    110 Linden Avenue, NY 12095

    Price

    $135,000

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    01/17/2025

    Address

    3389 State Highway 10, NY 12095

    Price

    $191,000

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    01/02/2025

    Address

    540 State Highway 10, NY 12032

    Price

    $307,000

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    11/07/2024

    Address

    304 Rappa Road, NY 12166

    Price

    $85,000

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    10/09/2024

    Address

    1908 STHWY 29, NY 12095

    Price

    $265,000

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    09/12/2024

    Address

    1 Young Avenue, NY 12010

    Price

    $120,000

    Represented

    N/A

    Date

    08/11/2024

    Address

    2304 State Highway 10, NY 12032

    Price

    $115,000

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    08/05/2024

    Address

    2296 Hickory Hill Rd, NY 12068

    Price

    $198,790

    Represented

    Buyer

    Ratings & Reviews (5)

    gregrog2

    stars rating

    3 months ago

    Don was great to work with from start to finish when buying our Sacandaga place. He was very knowledgeable about the market and local area. We are from out of state so having him there at various inspections was a lifesaver. His communications were always helpful and responsive on a variety of issues. We highly recommend Don for any real estate transactions!

    zuser20180313070954713

    stars rating

    4 months ago

    Don is a superb agent! I was a first time homebuyer and he always kept my best interest in mind. Don never pushed me to make an offer and answered any questions I had and even gave examples of previous things he had run into. We looked at over a dozen homes together before I settled on one and he stayed vigilant throughout the entire process. I would recommend Don to anyone looking for a home.

    mspoet0928

    stars rating

    7 months ago

    Donald Toscano was very helpful to us in finding a new home to buy and live in. He is knowledgeable about the area and was able to provide useful feedback on the properties that we viewed. We actually changed our minds on the day we were putting an offer in on one property to a different property, and he had the new offer paperwork ready to go in a few hours.

    blais 14590

    stars rating

    9 months ago

    Chuck and I (Mochamer) have only high praises for our buying and selling experiences with Don Toscano years ago when we first bought our home in Caroga Lake, NY and when we recently sold our home in Caroga Lake, NY. Don made every step along this process easy, explaining in detail every detail we needed to know as well as had a right to be made aware of. He was very professional but made you feel more like a family member by the way he took care of all the needs he felt were his responsibility as your realtor and selling agent. He made you feel safe and secure your back was covered. With Don taking such good care of all our needs, we felt very confident and relaxed. Don found a buyer and got an offer within an extremely short amount of time ! To say we are very happy with the service Don Toscano provided us both times would and is an under-statement. He is such a trustworthy person we feel confident he will always work his hardest to provide you with the best service and experience possible. Pamela & Charles Mochamer

    katew42

    stars rating

    1 year ago

    We were so lucky to end up with Don representing us as buyers for our new home! We discussed before going to our first showing that we weren't going to commit to the first realtor we met... Well then we met Don! Our personalities clicked with his right away. We really appreciated that he was willing to take a step back while we viewed homes and then provide input when and where we asked (which we did often). It took us a number of tries to find the right home for us, and Don was patient and kind through it all. While other parties of the closing were slow to respond or held up the process, Don always kept us in the know and on top of what step in the process we were in. His knowledge, attitude, and commitment to finding us the right home were exceptional.