Top Agent

    Nicole Annis

    Cardinal Realty LLC

    stars rating
    58

    Want to work with Nicole Annis?

    Top 2.35%

    In Appleton, WI

    $34.3M

    Total Sales Last Year

    20

    Years of Experience

    115

    Recent Transactions

    $190K - $800K

    Average Price Point

    Agent Bio

    Discover Agent Performance Insights on Nicole Annis. We Analyzed 570 Transactions To Help You Decide If Nicole Is The Best Real Estate Agent Near You.

    Office Location

    1047 N. Lynndale Ave.,Appleton,WI54914

    Home Sold by Nicole Annis

    Agent Achievements

    Veteran Agent

    Photo Pro

    Highly Rated

    Negotiation Skills

    Avg. Savings Off List Price

    $14,980

    Avg. % Negotiated Off List

    5.65%

    Nicole Annis's Recent Sales

    Date

    10/15/2025

    Address

    2029 Little Rapids Rd, WI 54115

    Price

    $430,000

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    10/14/2025

    Address

    2510 W Sunnyview Cir, WI 54914

    Price

    $425,000

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    10/14/2025

    Address

    335 Washington Ave, WI 54956

    Price

    $170,000

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    10/10/2025

    Address

    230 Maria St, WI 54130

    Price

    $269,500

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    10/10/2025

    Address

    1320 Katherine St, WI 54915

    Price

    $175,000

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    10/06/2025

    Address

    228 E Thornbrook Ln, WI 54915

    Price

    $665,800

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    10/02/2025

    Address

    564 Horton Ter, WI 54944

    Price

    $389,900

    Represented

    Buyer

    Date

    09/30/2025

    Address

    8019 Arrow Ln, WI 54940

    Price

    $435,000

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    09/30/2025

    Address

    212 E Norfolk Pl, WI 54911

    Price

    $345,000

    Represented

    Seller

    Date

    09/22/2025

    Address

    N1738 Maple Terrace Rd, WI 54942

    Price

    $399,900

    Represented

    Buyer

    Ratings & Reviews (5)

    brianna zychowski

    stars rating

    4 weeks ago

    Nicole has been our realtor through our first and now second home buying experience. This time around, she’s also assisted us in selling our first home as well. We cannot possibly say enough amazing things about working with her! She has kept us in her thoughts by going out of her way to acknowledge us as valued clients by sending thoughtful cards and small gifts for things like Christmas and our home anniversary! She actually found our first home for us, knowing what we were looking for and bringing it to our attention right away. She got us in for a showing before it hit the market. She’s always easily/quickly available for showings and any other questions we’ve had in our home buying process. She was even working to help us sell our home while on her company retreat this year. The girl just goes above and beyond for her clients! And now that we’ve been with her through the years, we’ve also been able to work with her team at Cardinal Realty, and they’ve also been amazing — following up promptly and efficiently with all the closing process emails. One of her staff even had to come help get us back in our house after the appraiser accidentally locked us out, and they helped at the drop of a hat on a Friday afternoon. If anyone has a kind of picky, tough to impress husband like mine (IYKYK), then you should know that my husband trusts Nicole whole-heartedly. If you’re buying and/or selling, it’s a no-brainer. Go with Nicole and her team at Cardinal Realty.

    maggie steffens1

    stars rating

    1 year ago

    Nicole was amazing to work with. She gave me a timeline for everything right in the beginning and walked me through the process. She was always there with any questions I had and the communication about showings, any appointments that were needed to be scheduled, any documents that needed to be done/signed, and really everything involved with the whole selling process was outstanding. I would recommend her to anyone.

    vnshdz

    stars rating

    1 year ago

    We just closed on our first home last week with the help of Lindsay. I don’t think my husband and I could have picked a better realtor. Lindsay was fun, professional, and always kept our interests & goals at the forefront of our conversations. There was never any pressure to do one thing over another either. We had soooo many questions as first time home buyers & we asked them all because Lindsay made us feel so comfortable. She advocated for us every time which was extremely reassuring. Honestly kind of sad we don’t get to continue seeing her because she was just that great!

    allisonleggler

    stars rating

    2 years ago

    Choosing Lindsay as our realtor was one of the best decisions we could have made during our home-buying process. As VA home buyers, the journey wasn't always smooth. With Lindsay, however, we felt supported every step of the way. Lindsay is skilled, knowledgeable, and resilient. She faced the challenges we encountered head-on, refusing to be deterred by multiple offers being turned down. Her commitment to helping us find our perfect home never wavered. Coupled with her great sense of humor, she made the process feel less like a task and more like a fun adventure. She was able to lighten the mood during stressful times and helped keep us optimistic. In short, Lindsay is a top-notch professional who goes the extra mile for her clients. Her dedication and perseverance turned our dream of homeownership into reality. We highly recommend Lindsay for anyone stepping into the real estate market.

    zuser20140809073602075

    stars rating

    2 years ago

    Nicole is amazing to work with. I highly recommend. She handled everything perfectly for our family. Nicole went above an beyond to make sure our home sold and we got top price and the purchase of our new home went smoothly.