Protecting your home involves more than just locking the doors. Two financial products often cause confusion among homeowners: home warranties and homeowners insurance. While they sound similar and both protect your investment, they serve fundamentally different purposes and cover entirely different risks.
Understanding the distinction between these products can save you thousands of dollars and prevent frustrating surprises when you need protection most. This guide breaks down everything you need to know about home warranties versus homeowners insurance, including when you need each, what they cost, and which providers deliver the best value.
Buying or Selling a Home?
A top-performing real estate agent can help you navigate the complexities of home protection, negotiate seller credits for warranties, and ensure you're fully prepared for homeownership.
Find a Top Agent Near YouThe Fundamental Difference Explained
At their core, these two products protect against completely different risks. Homeowners insurance protects against sudden, unexpected damage from disasters and accidents. Home warranties cover the gradual breakdown of appliances and systems due to normal wear and tear.
Think of it this way: if a tree falls through your roof during a storm, homeowners insurance covers the damage. If your air conditioner stops working because the compressor wore out after years of use, a home warranty covers the repair or replacement.
Home Warranty Covers
- HVAC system breakdowns
- Appliance failures (refrigerator, dishwasher, oven)
- Plumbing system issues
- Electrical system problems
- Water heater malfunctions
- Washer and dryer breakdowns
- Garage door openers
- Ceiling fans and exhaust fans
Homeowners Insurance Covers
- Fire and smoke damage
- Wind and hail damage
- Theft and vandalism
- Falling objects (trees, debris)
- Personal liability claims
- Water damage from burst pipes
- Lightning strikes
- Temporary living expenses
What Neither Product Covers
Understanding the gaps in coverage is just as important as knowing what's protected. Standard homeowners insurance typically excludes flood damage, earthquake damage, and normal wear and tear. Home warranties exclude pre-existing conditions (unless specified), improper installation, and cosmetic issues.
Important Coverage Gap
Neither home warranties nor standard homeowners insurance covers flood damage. If you live in a flood-prone area, you'll need separate flood insurance through the National Flood Insurance Program or a private insurer. According to FEMA, just one inch of flood water can cause more than $25,000 in damage.
Cost Comparison: What You'll Actually Pay
The costs for these products differ significantly, reflecting the different types of protection they provide. Here's what homeowners typically pay for each:
| Feature | Home Warranty | Homeowners Insurance |
|---|---|---|
| Average Annual Cost | $500-$700/year ($42-$58/month) | $2,100/year ($175/month) |
| Per-Claim Cost | $75-$150 service fee | $500-$2,500 deductible |
| Coverage Limits | $2,000-$7,000 per item/year | Dwelling value + liability |
| Required? | No, always optional | Required by most mortgage lenders |
| Covers Existing Issues? | Some providers cover pre-existing conditions | Only sudden, unexpected damage |
| Contract Length | Typically 1 year, renewable | Annual policy, auto-renews |
Regional Cost Variations
Homeowners insurance costs vary dramatically by location. States prone to natural disasters like Florida, Oklahoma, and Texas see premiums two to three times higher than states with milder weather patterns like Vermont or Hawaii. Home warranty costs, on the other hand, remain relatively consistent nationwide, with modest regional adjustments.
When Do You Need Each Product?
Homeowners Insurance: Required for Most Homeowners
If you have a mortgage, your lender almost certainly requires homeowners insurance. This isn't optional. Even if you own your home outright, going without homeowners insurance represents a significant financial risk. A single fire or major storm could result in losses exceeding hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Standard homeowners insurance (known as an HO-3 policy) includes four main types of coverage:
Dwelling Coverage
- Covers your home's structure
- Includes attached structures (garage, deck)
- Repairs or rebuilds after covered damage
- Should equal rebuilding cost, not market value
Personal Property Coverage
- Covers belongings inside your home
- Typically 50-70% of dwelling coverage
- Includes furniture, electronics, clothing
- May need riders for high-value items
Liability Protection
- Covers injuries to others on your property
- Pays legal fees if you're sued
- Standard coverage: $100,000-$300,000
- Umbrella policies add extra protection
Loss of Use Coverage
- Pays living expenses if home is uninhabitable
- Covers hotel, meals, temporary housing
- Typically 20% of dwelling coverage
- Available while home is being repaired
Home Warranty: Best for Certain Situations
Home warranties are optional but can provide valuable peace of mind in specific circumstances. Consider a home warranty if:
- You're buying an older home where appliances and systems may be nearing the end of their useful life
- You're a first-time homeowner without experience managing home repairs or a network of trusted contractors
- Your savings are limited and an unexpected $5,000 HVAC replacement would strain your budget
- You're selling a home and want to offer buyers added assurance (sellers often provide a one-year warranty)
- Your appliances and systems are aging but not yet ready for replacement
Pro Tip for Homebuyers
During negotiations, ask the seller to provide a one-year home warranty as part of the sale. This is a common practice that provides protection during your first year of ownership when you're still learning about the home's systems. A skilled real estate agent can help negotiate this on your behalf.
Top Home Warranty Companies
Not all home warranty providers deliver the same level of service or value. Based on customer satisfaction ratings, coverage options, and claims processing, these companies consistently earn high marks from homeowners.
Liberty Home Guard
Consistently earns the highest customer ratings in the industry with a 4.7 Google rating from 16,000+ reviews. Offers 40+ add-on options for customized coverage, allows you to choose your own contractor, and provides 12-hour average claim response times. Available in all 50 states with 24/7 customer support. Plans start around $50/month.
American Home Shield
The industry's oldest major provider (since 1971) covers undetectable pre-existing issues, items without maintenance records, and problems from improper installation. Offers three plan tiers with coverage limits up to $5,000 per item. Network of 16,000+ licensed contractors nationwide.
Home Warranty of America
Scores highest in customer satisfaction surveys with comprehensive coverage and competitive pricing. Features low service fees starting at $75 and high payout limits. Known for straightforward claims processing and responsive customer service.
Choice Home Warranty
Offers competitive pricing with $3,000 coverage limits across the board for systems and appliances. Contacts service providers within four hours of receiving your call. Two comprehensive plan options with extensive add-on coverage available, including residential sprinkler systems.
What to Look for in a Home Warranty Provider
When comparing home warranty companies, evaluate these key factors:
- Coverage limits: Higher limits mean better protection. Look for at least $2,000 per item/claim.
- Service call fees: Lower fees ($75-$100) save money over time, especially if you file multiple claims.
- Contractor network: Companies with large networks can typically dispatch technicians faster.
- Customer reviews: Look for consistent positive feedback on claim approval rates and response times.
- Exclusions: Read the fine print. Some companies exclude pre-existing conditions or require maintenance records.
- Cancellation policy: Most offer 30-day money-back guarantees. Check for cancellation fees after that period.
Working with a Top Agent Protects Your Investment
When buying a home, a knowledgeable real estate agent helps ensure you understand all aspects of protecting your investment, from negotiating home warranties to recommending thorough home inspections.
Get Matched with a Top AgentTop Homeowners Insurance Providers
Choosing the right homeowners insurance involves balancing cost, coverage, and customer service. These companies consistently rank among the best options for homeowners:
State Farm
The largest home insurer in the U.S. offers competitive rates, a vast agent network for personalized service, and strong financial stability. Known for straightforward claims processing and bundling discounts with auto insurance.
Amica
Consistently ranks highest in customer satisfaction surveys. Offers dividend payments to policyholders (you may get money back). Higher upfront costs but often better long-term value. Strong reputation for claims handling.
USAA
Available only to military members and their families. Offers some of the lowest rates in the industry with excellent customer service ratings. If you qualify, USAA is typically the best option.
Nationwide
Offers unique features like brand-name appliance replacement. Competitive pricing with extensive discount options. Strong financial ratings and widespread availability across all 50 states.
Tips for Saving on Homeowners Insurance
- Bundle policies: Combining home and auto insurance typically saves 10-25%
- Increase your deductible: Raising from $500 to $1,000 can reduce premiums by 10-20%
- Improve home security: Alarm systems, deadbolts, and smart home devices may qualify for discounts
- Shop annually: Rates change frequently; comparing quotes yearly ensures you're getting the best deal
- Ask about all discounts: New home, claims-free, loyalty, and renovation discounts are often available
Do You Need Both Products?
Homeowners insurance is essentially non-negotiable for most homeowners due to lender requirements. The question becomes whether adding a home warranty makes financial sense for your situation.
Consider a Home Warranty If:
- Your appliances are 5-10+ years old
- You don't have an emergency fund for repairs
- You're not handy or lack contractor relationships
- You're a first-time homeowner
- The home's systems are aging (HVAC, water heater)
Skip the Home Warranty If:
- Your appliances and systems are new
- You have substantial savings for emergencies
- You're handy and can handle basic repairs
- You have trusted contractors on speed dial
- Your home is newly constructed
Many homeowners find that during the first few years after purchasing an older home, a warranty provides valuable protection during the period when they're learning about the home's quirks and building their contractor network. After establishing themselves, some choose to self-insure by setting aside the warranty premium amount in an emergency fund instead.
Understanding the Claims Process
Filing a Home Warranty Claim
When an appliance or system breaks down, home warranty claims typically follow this process:
- Report the issue: Contact your warranty company online or by phone. Most accept claims 24/7.
- Pay the service fee: You'll pay your service call fee ($75-$150) when the technician arrives.
- Technician diagnosis: A contractor from the warranty company's network inspects the problem.
- Approval and repair: If covered, the warranty company approves repair or replacement.
- Completion: The technician completes the work, typically within 24-48 hours for most repairs.
Filing a Homeowners Insurance Claim
Insurance claims for property damage involve more documentation:
- Document everything: Take photos and videos of all damage before cleaning or repairs.
- Prevent further damage: Make temporary repairs if needed (keep receipts).
- Contact your insurer: Report the claim as soon as possible.
- Meet with the adjuster: An insurance adjuster will assess the damage.
- Receive your payout: After deductible, you'll receive funds for repairs/replacement.
Important Reminder
Keep detailed records of your home's contents and condition. A home inventory with photos makes insurance claims significantly smoother. Many insurance companies offer free apps to help you document your belongings. Reviewing your policy annually ensures your homeowners insurance coverage keeps pace with your home's value.
Frequently Asked Questions
No state law requires homeowners insurance. However, if you have a mortgage, your lender almost certainly requires it as a condition of your loan. Even without a mortgage, going without insurance puts your largest asset at significant risk.
Most home warranty companies require you to use contractors from their network. However, some providers like Liberty Home Guard and America's First Choice Home Club allow you to choose your own contractor (subject to approval). This can be valuable if you have established relationships with trusted local technicians.
Homeowners insurance covers appliances only if they're damaged by a covered peril like fire, theft, or storm damage. It does not cover appliances that break down due to age, wear and tear, or mechanical failure. That's where a home warranty comes in.
Both are out-of-pocket costs, but they work differently. An insurance deductible (typically $500-$2,500) is the amount you pay before insurance kicks in for any claim that year. A warranty service fee ($75-$150) is paid each time a technician visits your home, regardless of previous claims.
It depends on your situation. A home warranty averaging $600/year can pay for itself with a single major repair (HVAC systems can cost $3,000-$7,000 to replace). For older homes or homeowners without emergency savings, warranties often provide good value. For newer homes with new appliances, self-insuring through an emergency fund may make more sense.
This varies significantly by provider. American Home Shield is known for covering undetectable pre-existing issues and items without maintenance records. Many other companies exclude pre-existing conditions. Always read the contract carefully before purchasing.
Standard homeowners insurance covers sudden and accidental water damage, like from a burst pipe or appliance malfunction. It typically does not cover flood damage (from rising water entering the home), gradual water damage, or damage from lack of maintenance. Flood insurance requires a separate policy.
Yes. Most home warranty companies offer a 30-day money-back guarantee. After that period, you can typically cancel and receive a prorated refund, minus a cancellation fee (often $50). Review your contract for specific terms before purchasing.
Your dwelling coverage should equal the cost to rebuild your home (not its market value). Get a replacement cost estimate from your insurer or a contractor. Personal property coverage should reflect the total value of your belongings. Consider increasing liability coverage if you have significant assets to protect.
Many sellers offer a one-year home warranty as a selling point. It provides buyers peace of mind and can protect sellers from post-sale claims about appliance or system failures. The cost (typically $400-$700) is often worth it for the added buyer confidence it provides.
Making the Right Choice for Your Home
Understanding the difference between home warranties and homeowners insurance is essential for properly protecting your investment. Homeowners insurance is a must-have that protects against catastrophic damage. Home warranties are a nice-to-have that can provide peace of mind and budget protection against unexpected repair costs.
For most homeowners, especially those purchasing older homes or those without substantial emergency savings, having both forms of protection makes sense. The combined cost of roughly $2,700-$2,800 annually provides comprehensive protection against both sudden disasters and gradual wear and tear.
Before making decisions about either product, consult with a knowledgeable real estate professional who can help you understand the specific needs of your property and situation. A top agent can also help negotiate seller-paid warranties and connect you with trusted local insurance professionals.
Ready to Find Your Perfect Home?
Connect with a top-performing real estate agent who will guide you through every step of the buying or selling process, from home protection to closing day.
Get Started Today
