TL;DR
The price gap between new construction and existing homes has narrowed to historic lows, with Q1 2025 showing just a $14,600 median difference. New construction offers modern layouts, energy efficiency, and builder warranties (typically 1-2-10 year coverage), while resale homes provide established neighborhoods and often lower upfront costs. Builder incentives like mortgage rate buydowns to the 4-5% range, closing cost credits up to $100,000, and free upgrades are making new builds increasingly competitive. Regardless of which path you choose, working with a buyer's agent protects your interests and costs you nothing extra since builders typically pay the commission.
Find the Perfect Agent for Your Home Purchase
Whether you're buying new construction or a resale home, a top-performing agent can negotiate better terms and protect your investment.
Get Matched With a Top AgentThe True Cost: New Construction vs. Resale Homes
One of the biggest surprises for today's homebuyers is how dramatically the price difference between new and existing homes has shrunk. According to NAHB data, the median price for a new single-family home in Q1 2025 was $416,900, compared to $402,300 for an existing home. That $14,600 gap represents a historic low.
To put this in perspective, in Q4 2022, new homes commanded a $64,200 premium over existing properties. The decade average from 2010-2019 showed a gap of $66,000. What changed? Builders have responded to affordability challenges by constructing smaller homes on smaller lots, shifting more construction to the less expensive South region, and offering aggressive incentives.
Something remarkable happened in Q2 and Q3 of 2024: for the first time since 1989, existing home prices actually exceeded new home prices. While that anomaly has since reversed, it illustrates how tight inventory in the resale market continues driving up existing home prices while builder competition keeps new construction prices in check.
Regional Price Variations
Where you buy significantly impacts the new vs. resale calculation. The Midwest offers the most affordable options, with new homes selling for a median of $367,500 compared to $297,800 for existing homes in Q1 2025. The South follows closely with new homes at $376,000 versus $361,800 for resale properties.
The price dynamics also differ by region. Southern markets have seen robust new home construction, which has actually led to some price declines. NAR Chief Economist Lawrence Yun notes that these price drops should be viewed as temporary opportunities for buyers who were previously priced out.
Builder Incentives: The Game-Changer
Today's builder incentives represent some of the most aggressive offers in recent memory. According to NAHB data, roughly 60% of builders offered special incentives between June 2024 and February 2025, while about one-third lowered base prices by an average of 5%.
Mortgage Rate Buydowns
Builders buying rates down to 4.75%-5.99%, with some offering rates as low as 2.99% in the first year through 3-2-1 buydown programs
Closing Cost Credits
Credits ranging from $5,000 to $100,000+ toward closing costs, with typical incentives at 2-5% of sale price
Free Upgrades
Premium finishes, appliance packages, extended outdoor living, and design studio credits valued at $15,000-$70,000
Extended Rate Locks
Lock in today's rate for 90-360 days while your home is under construction, protecting against rate increases
Understanding Rate Buydowns
Permanent rate buydowns have become the builder's favorite tool, with 64% of new homes sold by large builders using this incentive as of mid-2025. Here's why they're so valuable: for every 1% reduction in your mortgage rate, you save roughly $105 per month on a $400,000 loan. That adds up to over $37,000 in savings over a 30-year mortgage.
Buydowns come in two forms:
Temporary Buydowns (2-1 or 3-2-1)
- Rate reduced 2-3% in year one, gradually increasing
- 3-2-1 example: 3.875% year one, 4.875% year two, 5.875% year three
- Helps with initial affordability while income grows
- Best for buyers expecting income increases
Permanent Buydowns
- Lower rate for the entire 30-year loan term
- Builder pays upfront points at closing
- Average discount of 1.3 percentage points
- Costs builder roughly 3.2% of sale price per 1% rate reduction
Builder Warranties: Protection Resale Homes Can't Match
One of the most significant advantages of new construction is comprehensive warranty coverage. Most builder warranties follow a 1-2-10 structure that protects different components for different periods.
According to the Federal Trade Commission, these warranties typically cover items that are permanent parts of the home. If something covered by the warranty fails during the coverage period, the builder must repair or replace it, or reimburse you for the cost.
What's Not Covered
Builder warranties have limitations you should understand:
Typical Exclusions
Builder warranties generally exclude: damage from homeowner neglect or weather events, manufactured products covered by separate manufacturer warranties (like appliances), landscaping and outbuildings, damage from unauthorized modifications or repairs, and normal wear and tear. The warranty also won't cover living expenses if you need to move out during major repairs.
Hidden Costs: The Full Picture
When comparing new construction to resale homes, sticker price tells only part of the story. Both options come with costs that may not be immediately obvious.
| Cost Factor | New Construction | Resale Home |
|---|---|---|
| Immediate Repairs | Minimal to none; everything is new | Average $12,000+ for homes over 20 years old |
| Upgrades & Customization | 10-20% of base price for builder upgrades; premium charges apply | Renovation costs vary widely; more flexibility but higher labor costs |
| Landscaping | Often bare lot; budget $5,000-$25,000 for basic landscaping | Usually established; maintenance only |
| Energy Costs | 20-30% lower utility bills with modern efficiency standards | Higher heating/cooling costs without updates |
| Maintenance (Years 1-5) | Minimal; warranty covers most issues | Budget 1-3% of home value annually |
| HOA Fees | Often higher in new communities with amenities | Varies; established communities may have lower fees |
| Property Taxes | May be based on higher assessment | Established assessment; may increase after purchase |
The Energy Efficiency Advantage
New homes built to current codes are significantly more energy efficient than older properties. They feature better insulation, high-performance windows, Energy Star-rated appliances, and modern HVAC systems. This translates to measurably lower utility bills and increased comfort.
For resale homes, achieving similar efficiency often requires substantial investment: new windows ($10,000-$30,000), insulation upgrades ($2,000-$8,000), and HVAC replacement ($5,000-$15,000). These costs should factor into your total purchase calculation.
Compare Your Options With Expert Guidance
A top real estate agent can help you analyze total costs, negotiate builder incentives, and find the best value whether you choose new or resale.
Find Your AgentTimeline and Flexibility Considerations
Your timeline significantly impacts whether new construction or resale is the better choice. Here's what to expect:
New Construction Timeline
- Spec/Inventory Homes: Move-in ready or within 30-60 days
- To-Be-Built: 6-12 months from contract to close
- Custom Homes: 12-18+ months including design phase
- Delays possible due to weather, permits, material availability
- Flexibility to sell existing home on your timeline
Resale Home Timeline
- Typical closing: 30-45 days from accepted offer
- Move-in ready upon closing (unless renovating)
- May face competition and multiple offer situations
- Inspection contingencies could extend timeline
- May need to coordinate sale of current home
For buyers with flexible timelines, new construction's longer process can actually be advantageous. You can sell your current home without the pressure of coordinating closing dates, and you might benefit from quarter-end or year-end builder incentives.
Location: Where New Construction Falls Short
One area where resale homes often win is location. New single-family construction typically occurs on the outskirts of metropolitan areas where land is available and affordable. This often means:
Location Considerations for New Construction
Longer commutes to urban job centers, less walkability to shops and restaurants, newer schools that may lack established reputations, limited public transit access, and communities that lack the mature landscaping and character of established neighborhoods. However, many planned communities offset these factors with amenities like pools, parks, fitness centers, and walking trails.
Resale homes offer more location flexibility, including urban infill properties, historic neighborhoods, and areas with mature trees and established community character. If proximity to work, specific schools, or urban amenities tops your priority list, the resale market likely offers more options.
Customization: New Construction's Clear Advantage
If creating a home tailored to your lifestyle matters, new construction offers unmatched opportunities.
What You Can Customize
Depending on when you enter the building process, customization options range from selecting lot position and floor plan orientation to choosing every finish in the home. Early-stage buyers might influence room configurations, ceiling heights, and electrical layouts. Even buyers of spec homes typically have some finish selection opportunities.
Common customization categories include flooring materials and colors, cabinet styles and hardware, countertop surfaces, lighting fixtures and placement, paint colors throughout, appliance packages, smart home technology integration, and outdoor living features.
Why You Need Agent Representation With Builders
A common misconception is that buyers save money by not using a real estate agent when purchasing new construction. The reality is quite different.
The Builder's Agent Works for the Builder
The sales representative at the model home or sales center has a fiduciary duty to the builder, not to you. While they're knowledgeable and often helpful, their job is to represent the builder's interests and maximize the sale price.
New construction contracts are written by builder attorneys to protect the builder. Common provisions that favor builders include escalation clauses allowing price increases, limited recourse if completion dates slip, strict deposit forfeiture terms, and arbitration requirements that waive your right to legal action.
What Your Agent Brings to the Table
A buyer's agent experienced in new construction provides critical value:
Negotiation & Analysis
- Negotiating price reductions, upgrades, or additional incentives
- Comparing builder financing against market alternatives
- Identifying which upgrades deliver value vs. those that don't
- Understanding when builders are most motivated to deal
Protection & Oversight
- Reviewing contracts and recommending modifications
- Attending construction walkthroughs and documenting progress
- Creating punch lists and coordinating corrections
- Ensuring the finished product matches specifications
Commission Doesn't Come From Your Pocket
Here's the key point: builders factor agent commissions into their business costs. If you don't bring an agent, the builder simply keeps that money. They don't pass savings to you. As one industry expert notes, builders will not credit buyers the commission they would otherwise pay to an agent because doing so would discourage agents from bringing future clients.
Following the 2024 NAR settlement, some commission structures have evolved, but most builders continue compensating buyer's agents because they recognize the value agents bring in creating smooth transactions. An experienced agent working on your behalf can negotiate better terms while costing you nothing out of pocket.
Making Your Decision: A Framework
Neither new construction nor resale is universally "better." The right choice depends on your specific circumstances, priorities, and market conditions.
| Consider New Construction If: | Consider Resale If: |
|---|---|
| You want modern layouts and technology | You need specific location/neighborhood |
| Energy efficiency is a priority | You prefer architectural character/history |
| You want warranty protection | You need to move quickly |
| Customization matters to you | You want established landscaping |
| You can take advantage of builder incentives | Urban access is essential |
| Your timeline is flexible | You prefer a shorter transaction |
| You want predictable maintenance costs | Budget constraints favor lower upfront price |
Get Expert Guidance on Your Home Purchase
EffectiveAgents matches you with top-performing agents who have proven track records in your local market. Our agents have helped buyers save $2.1B+ and maintain a 98% satisfaction rate.
Find a Top-Performing Agent
